Home Messages Index
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
Author IndexDate IndexThread Index

Re: [wp-hackers] WordPress and GPLv3

Roy Schestowitz:

[...] While much of the coversation has drifted towards Tivoization, which is
the more controversial part of the licence, I worry more about other
aspects, such as software patents.
[...] There are companies with very broad
patent portfolios and even prior art would cost a fortune to get hold of
and show in a court a law. [...]

About GPL3, my personal alert is user's *real* freedom.
As the linux kernel developers said [1]:

"While we find the use of DRM by media companies in their attempts to reach into user owned devices to control content deeply disturbing, our belief in the essential freedoms of section 3 forbids us from ever accepting any licence which contains end use restrictions."

I think that there's many aspect of that licence that WILL create some trouble to the WordPress community, from keeping probably-distinct licence information for every external library involved in the codebase, to a notable loss of code and contributions, and worst of all, this will happens because WordPress has a conservative approach on some things, but acts the opposite about its licence. Quite nasty.

I feel like GPL3 is a long and unreadable way to say "we used to trust you people, but since some of you aren't nice, we let you have almost- all-your-freedom". I think that's not nice - to many of us in this list - hear this from WordPress.

This is a matter of attitude, in the WordPress scenario: compatibily vs. lobbying. And for the same reason Matt and the core team choose to not support "go php5" campaign, I think that WordPress needs to remain GPL2.

And please trust me, I'm not used to mix math with code: the *reason* for both were the same, the *matter* - obviously - not. :-)

[1] http://lwn.net/Articles/200422/

Paolo Tresso
- pixline.net code monkey
http://pixline.net - http://amisnet.org

wp-hackers mailing list

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
Author IndexDate IndexThread Index