Vista copy protection is defended
,----[ Quote ]
| In a report looking at the impact Vista would have on video and
| audio playback, he described Vista's Content Protection specification
| as "the longest suicide note in history".
|
| He said Vista was "broken by design" and intentionally crippled the
| way it displayed video.
|
| "The sheer obnoxiousness of Vista's content protection may end up
| being the biggest incentive to piracy yet created," he wrote.
`----
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/6286245.stm
Perhaps [H]omer's open letter to the BBC (viewed over a thousand times and
reached the FSF) played a role and had a real impact.
As Gutmann says, more reason to upgrade to Linux (not Apple).
Related:
Peter Gutmann on Vista DRM
,----[ Snippet ]
| Leo: So the insane paranoia really comes from Hollywood, not from
| Microsoft.
|
| PETER: It's hard to tell what goes on inside Microsoft. But if you
| read the technical specs, I think any technical person that reads
| those specs would say this is never going to work, and half of the
| stuff is nuts. On the other hand, it could well be high-level managers
| inside Microsoft who don't understand the technology and who
| completely agree with Hollywood and who think we should do this
| even though other people have told me it's impossible, we're
| going to do it anyway.
`----
http://www.grc.com/sn/SN-074.htm
The Longest Suicide Note in History
,----[ Quote ]
| On the same podcast Gutmann scotched suggestions Microsoft were held
| to ransom by Hollywood;
|
| [...]
|
| The genie's out of the bottle before the operating system has even
| been released! But that doesn't mean Vista users in particular - and
| the computer community at large - won't end up paying for Microsoft's
| DRM folly. At the risk of repeating myself repeating myself, yet
| another reason to move to Linux.
`----
http://blogs.pcworld.co.nz/pcworld/tux-love/2007/01/the_longest_suicide_note_in_hi.html
Sun Blogs: Comments on Peter Gutmann's Vista paper
,----[ Quote ]
| Overall, I agree with Gutmann that what is being attempted is
| fundamentally impossible - although I don't agree with all the
| consequences he draws. Further, I believe that software vendors
| have no right to dictate what hardware vendors produce. I also
| must say that Note C made me grin, being Gutmann's view on DRM.
|
| Finally, I can't see any Sun hardware ever being certified to
| run Vista, since the apparent need (as described in the article)
| to keep hardware details secret goes against our philosophy
| (even SPARC is famously open-source, see VHDL for a SPARC v8
| implementation and our own Verilog of the T1 SPARC v9).
`----
http://blogs.sun.com/davew/entry/comments_on_peter_gutmann_s
Cost analysis of Vista DRM: Part II
,----[ Quote ]
| Microsoft doesn't merely use DRM. To all intents and purposes it
| is DRM, better known as Digital Rights Management, Digital
| Restrictions Management or or just plain CRAP for Content
| Restriction, Annulment, and Protection, as ZDNet's David
| Berlind called it, eventually deferring to Richard Stallman's
| Cancellation, Restriction, and Punishment. We call it, simply,
| CCG, short for Consumer Control Gear.
`----
http://p2pnet.net/story/10827
|
|
