Why the XO Laptop is better than the Classmate
,----[ Quote ]
| There's been some awful FUD flying around the OLPC world in the last few
| days, with misquotes, misinformation, and flat out lies being propagated left
| and right. Even Engadget, one of the better geektech blogs out there, got it
| completely wrong regarding OLPC CTO Mary Lou Jepsen's departure from the
| project.
|
| [...]
|
| Classmate is more expensive, consumes 10 times the power, has 1/3 the wifi
| ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
| range, and can't be used outside. Also, the Classmate doesn't use neighboring
| laptops to extend the reach of the internet via hopping (mesh-networking)
| like the XO does. So not only is the XO cheaper than the Classmate, the XO
| requires less infrastructre expenditure for electricity and for internet
| access.
`----
http://planet-geek.com/archives/004331.html
Remember that Intel had to dump (cover the cost of) its product to suppress
OLPC (charity, so therefor cannot sell at a loss), e.g. in Nigeria.
It's like a subtle form of bribe, just like those kickbacks they used against
AMD... and then faced lawsuits for in at least three continents, including
this new one:
Today's Lesson: Do Not F**k with the Negroponte Brothers
,----[ Quoet ]
| My own speculation: with his brother in a high position, Nicholas Negroponte
| is not in the mood to lie down to Intel's (Microsoft's) co-manipulations here
| at the low end of the important education laptop segment. Not calling in a
| favor from the Empire State, or from Andrew Cuomo personally, may be too hard
| to resist, but it is the Negroponte's responsibility to apply pressure on the
| ugly establishment in whatever ways they are able. (I have no information
| that John Negroponte has involved himself in this matter. That conclusion is
| purely speculation on my part.)
|
| Intel's cash costs and opportunity costs (in terms of further management
| distractions) are going up just through the New York State lawsuit, alone.
| That will proceed whatever the outcome, whether Intel joins OLPC and plays
| fair (which it may have to do to achieve the best outcome for itself).
`----
http://fussnotes.typepad.com/plexnex/2008/01/do-not-fk-with.html
Related:
Intel-powered XO is too expensive and consumes too much power
,----[ Quote ]
| 2 days before Intel CEO Paul Otellini would unveil the Classmate 2 or the
| Intel-powered XO at the CES, Intel announced that they are quitting the OLPC
| board.
|
| Intel claims that they are quitting because of Nicholas Negroponte wanting
| them to stop the promotion of the Classmate/Eee to education in third world
| countries, but I think that the real reason is that Intel does not have a
| good enough processor for the OLPC project to use as an alternative to the
| AMD Geode LX-700. Intel has not been able to develop a processor to match the
| price, power consumption and performance requirements of the OLPC project.
| Paul Otellini could have looked like a fool at the CES if he had to unveil an
| Intel powered XO that was performing worse in terms of price and power
| consumption compared to the AMD powered one.
`----
http://charbax.com/2008/01/04/intel-diamondville-and-menlow-processors-not-low-costpower-enough/
Intel: doing the dirty on OLPC
,----[ Quote ]
| Intel’s agreement with the OLPC Foundation included a ‘non disparagement’
| clause, under which Intel and One Laptop promised not to criticize each
| other, according to Nicholas Negroponte in the latest article in the Wall
| Street Journal.
|
| Still Intel tactics have violated that repeatedly to kill OLPC efforts in
| Nigeria, Libya, Pakistan, India, China and Intel is also still trying to pull
| those tactics in Mexico, Brazil.
| This is simply disgracefull of Intel, scandalous.
|
| But Negroponte has signed an agreement saying that he is not allowed to
| criticize Intel, so he is not allowed to talk about these shameless tactics
| even though Intel is the one violating the agreement.
|
| So only independant voices on the Internet can get those messages of truth
| out about Intels tactics.
|
| In Nigeria, Intel came and donated 3000 laptops to counter OLPC efforts, then
| sells 17 thousand Classmates to Nigeria at a loss.
|
| Then Microsoft corrupted Nigerian officials with 400 thousand dollars to
| install Windows XP on those instead of Mandriva Linux.
`----
http://www.p2pnet.net/story/14124
|
|
