Home Messages Index
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
Author IndexDate IndexThread Index

Re: Gary M. Stewart (aka “Flatfish”) About Microsoft AstroTurfing: “It’s made me A LOT of money….”



Roy Schestowitz wrote:
[copied from my blog post]

“You’re right. Some of the evangelism practices that I taught
and executed at Microsoft in the 1990’s were unethical. I
didn’t think so at the time — I thought that they were just
hyper-competitive — but I agree now.”

–James Plamondon, former Microsoft ’shills chief’

LAST WEEK we showed solid proof that Microsoft was paying
people for what’s known as “AstroTurfing”. It’s part of the
company’s strategy and policy — always has been. The men at
the very top — those who are responsible for this — are
Marshall Goldberg and James Plamondon.

Some people remember “Steve Barkto”, who was exposed by a
newspaper for being a Microsoft agent [1, 2, 3, 4]. Gary M.
Stewart may be another such agent, who has posted under
literally hundreds of names in mediums that include USENET,
Digg, Slashdot, even Netscape/ Propeller, where he libeled,
embarrassed, threatened, gave fake testimonies, stole
identities and — above all — viciously attacked everything and
everyone that competes with Microsoft. This has gone on for
over a decade, and that’s just one person (there are more).

[snip]

From: "Gary M. Stewart" &ltgmstewart1953@xxxxxxxxx>
Subject: Re: Another user loves Ubuntu
Date: Thu, 1 Jan 2009 21:01:48 -0500
Message-ID: &ltgjjshp$bmi$1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
X-No-Archive: YES

[...] Don Zeigler wrote:

How I Wasted My Life Trolling COLA

by Gary Stewart, aka flatfish and about 600 other nyms

It’s made me A LOT of money…. A Best Seller you might say……

Roy, it is obvious no matter how much the Wintrolls will deny it. There is active astroturfing going on, through the likes of the posts from Gary M. Stewart, DFS, Erik Funkenbusch, Tim Smith, amicus_curious, clogwog and nyms (Rick Mather), Hadron Quark and a few lesser trolls. It is obvious that they communicate and coordinate.

EU has made strides for fairness in competition; there, such activity is considered illegal. However, most of those trolls including clogwog live outside the EU and are not subject to EU law (as Marti found out regarding clogwog).

Regarding Snit AKA Rhino Plastee and a few other nyms (Michael Glasser), it is possible too, although currently he seems to be nothing more than a nut case.

Linux is considerably more stable, inherently less viral prone than Microsoft Windows. Apple OSX based on BSD Unix variant also follows suite, why some able to afford prefer it.

In spite of all the nasty FUD these astroturfers toss up, Linux is gaining. Because windows has dominated the microcomputer desktop environment (and perpetuated for a time due to uncompetitive monopoly maintenance), it has been an initial slow climb for Linux.

For example, look at all the lawsuits with Microsoft as defendant:

http://www.theinquirer.net/en/inquirer/news/2005/07/14/microsofts-law...

or http://tinyurl.com/59wley

[quote]
Microsoft's lawsuit payouts amount to around $9 billion
Updated Twice the GDP of Cambodia
By Désiré Athow: Thursday, 14 July 2005, 2:35 PM
* UPDATE Additional material at the end of this article.

MICROSOFT HAS had a long, a very long history of litigation,
court orders, patent infringements and antitrust lawsuits against
it since the very beginning of its history. We;ve managed to draw
up a partial list of these.

The surprising thing is not only the number of those lawsuits
against Microsoft - at one time, it had more than 130 pending -
but more importantly, the sheer amount of money it represents.

The Redmond giant has been ordered to pay nearly $9 billion, a
figure which is set to rise with some lawsuits still to be ruled on.

[.... Table below rearranged according to award amount, header added]

Award Amount    Plaintiff
--------------  ------------------
$1,950,000,000  Sun
$1,100,000,000  California
$850,000,000    IBM
$750,000,000    AOL
$613,000,000    EU
$536,000,000    Novell
$521,000,000    Eolas
$500,000,000    DR DOS/Caldera
$440,000,000    Intertrust
$250,000,000    Apple
$240,000,000    Minnesota
$202,000,000    Florida
$150,000,000    Gateway
$104,600,000    Arizona
$96,000,000     Perma Temps
$89,000,000     North Carolina
$83,000,000     Stac
$64,000,000     Tennessee
$62,000,000     SPX
$60,000,000     Burst
$35,000,000     Immersion
$34,000,000     Massachusett
$32,000,000     Kansas
$23,250,000     Be
$22,600,000     Nebraska state
$12,300,000     Montana
$10,500,000     Maryland
$10,500,000     Private (5)
$9,700,000      Vermont
$9,330,000      South Dakota
$9,000,000      Employee fired (3)
$9,000,000      North Dakota
$8,960,000      Carlos Armando (1)
$8,600,000      Daum (4)
$6,200,000      Columbia
$4,100,000      Bristol
$3,150,000      New Mexico
$2,000,000      Iowa
Undisclosed     Alacritech
Undisclosed     AT&T
Undisclosed     Sendo
Still in court? Discrimation Suit (2)
Still in court  E-data
Still in court  Forgent
Still in court  Go
Still in court  Mythic
Still in court  Wordperfect suit
Still in court  Real

[...] * UPDATE Thanks to Groklaw and Mr. Jaffar for their
assistance. Ten more cases have now been added and the total in
the coffer now exceeds the $9 billion mark:

Time Line Settled, undisclosed
Ticketmaster Settled, undisclosed
Priceline Still in court?
Goldtouch technology Settled, undisclosed
Syn'x $ 250,000
eLeaders Settled, undisclosed
e-Pass Still in court
Roger Avary (6) Still in court
Arendi Holdings Still in court?
Borland $100,000,000
[/quote]

The lawsuits continue:

http://www.linux-magazine.com/online/news/new_case_against_microsoft_brought_to_european_commission

or http://tinyurl.com/6k7j6d

[quote]
New Case Against Microsoft Brought To European Commission
Dec 01, 2008

The Dutch software dealer HW Trading has proffered a complaint concerning Microsoft's marketing practices to the European Trade Commission. The reason: Microsoft has for years been selling its products at a higher price in Europe than it does in America.
[/quote]

Going back to Linux succeeding, if you think about it, outside US, the educational and business sectors are more Linux friendly than US. Even in US, Linux deployments do not often make mainline news because of the lack of paid for advertising, which Linux does not need. Following are news leaks:

Regarding Kerala, India's 12,500 high schools now embracing Linux and FOSS:

http://www.networkgulf.com/newngit/index.php/Industry-News/kerala-
high-schools-complete-the-migration-to-linux-and-open-source

or http://tinyurl.com/7jkcuo

[quote]
Kerala high schools complete the migration to Linux and Open source
Indian Express - Wednesday, March 5, 2008

Kerala is all set to become the first state in India to completely banish Microsoft and allow only GNU/Linux free software to be used in the mandatory IT test at the state SSLC examinations that half a million students will appear for from next week. Till last year, they could take the exam using either free software or the Microsoft platform. Not anymore.

A few weeks ago, the Government formally ordered that only free Linux-based software should be used for IT education in high schools, using new the Linux text books developed by State Council for Educational Research and Training and the Free Software Foundation of India.

The state government's anti-proprietary planks apart, another major plus of abandoning Microsoft, claim state IT Mission officials, is plainly the cost factor. “Going for a massive Windows-based infrastructure cost a lot. Linux can bundle all applications with the operating system facilitating a single installation kit”.
[/quote]

http://piacentini.livejournal.com/7871.html

[quote]
ProInfo and Linux Educacional - KDE in Public Schools in Brazil
* Apr. 23rd, 2008 at 6:09 PM

One of the highlights of fisl9.0 for me was getting to know better the work that is being done by Brazil's Ministry of Education (MEC). They have just unveiled the numbers for the ongoing ProInfo project. What is interesting about this project is that it not only provides infrastructure (computers and net connectivity) but also open content to students in public schools.

The software installed on these systems is "Linux Educacional 2.0", a very clean Debian-based distribution, with KDE 3.5, KDE-Edu, KDE-Games, and some tools developed by the project.

[...]

As this first slide shows, until the end of this year there will be already 29,000 labs deployed, serving approximately 36 million students. This number grows to more than 53,000 by the end of 2009, and at that time 52 million students will have access to them. You can also see in the slide a solution that is being developed for classrooms: a single hardware unit with integrated projector, cpu, bundled content and DVD player. With it, digital content will no longer be restricted to the info lab, and will be usable by teachers in the traditional classrooms as well.
[/quote]

http://ec.europa.eu/idabc/en/document/7386/469

[quote]
EU: Schools increase use of Open Source
Open Source News - 26 February 2008 - EU and Europe-wide - General

Schools using GNU/Linux or other Open Source systems for desktop
PCs are no longer rare, though in many countries their numbers
are very low. Not so in India, Macedonia, the Philippines, Russia
and Turkey, where hundreds of thousands of pupils are becoming
familiar with Open Source.

This type of software will become more prominent in education,
expects Datamonitor, a research firm. In a report published last
month it predicts that spending on Open Source software,
including maintenance and services, by the education sector
globally will reach $489.9 million by 2012, compared to $286.2
million today.

[....]

However popular these laptops may become, the number of Western
European classrooms were Open Source software is being used
daily, is dwarfed  by those in countries like Macedonia, Turkey
and Russia.

In Macedonia, a 180.000 PCs running the GNU/Linux distribution
Ubuntu are being deployed in schools across the country. In
Turkey all students aged 11 and 12 will find Open Source on their
schools PCs as an option next to Microsoft Windows. And in
Russia, the government last year decided to migrate all schools
to GNU/Linux, a move that should be completed by 2009.
[/quote]

Such a threat to the Microsoft Corporation it is, that Chairman
Gates with his little Redmond book made the following statement:

[quote]
The increasing popularity of Open Source is one possible reason
for Microsoft chairman Bill Gates' recent announcement in Davos
to increase the companies' activities in the education market.
"Over the next three years we want to double the number of
students we get to and the number of teachers we get to, to
address the opportunity there."
[/quote]

Imagine that, 180,000 PC's, all with Linux installed.  This is
just one country, but then there are others.

No wonder why Venezuela's Banco Mercantil and Northern California
Windsor School District have decided on Linux and Open Source,
along with all these (Linux deployment sampler, incomplete):

      20,000 Singapore Ministry of Defence
   3,500,000 India
      80,000 Extremadura, Spain
      80,000 Générale des Impôts, France
      62,000 Ministry of Equipment, France
       1,154 Parliament, France
       4,000 Federal Public Justice Service, Belgium
         600 Central Bank, Turkey
         300 Scientific and Technological Research Council, Turkey
       1,000 Ministry of Water Resources, Turkey
         300 Istanbul City Health Directorate, Turkey
      12,000 Lower Saxony Tax Authority, Germany
         150 Ministry of Finance, Macedonia
      10,000 Department of Justice, Finland
       1,500 Metropolitan Court, Budapest, Hungary
      58,000 Berlin, Germany
         400 Largo City Offices, Florida
      14,000 Post Office, Brazil
      32,000 Government, Brazil
     464,000 Brazil schools (848K by 2009)
       2,205 North West Province Schools, South Africa
      15,000 Ministry of Education, Portugal
      20,000 Indianna Department of Education, US
     100,000 Macedonia Schools (estimated, 180K by 2009)

Here is something said of Windsor:

http://searchenterpriselinux.techtarget.com/news/article/0,289142,sid...

or http://tinyurl.com/5p5x5o

[quote]
The new setup also allows for better remote management. "[With
Windows] we had spent half our time driving around; we had to
touch every machine," Carver said. In a school system like
Windsor, all that driving was costing an already strapped IT
department too many resources.

Carver said it cost the district about $2,500 per school to
migrate to Linux, compared with the estimated $100,000 it would
have cost to upgrade their Windows infrastructure. In addition,
buying more Microsoft Office licenses would have cost the
district $100 per license, she said, whereas OpenOffice was free.

Linux as a learning tool

Ultimately, moving to Linux has enabled the Windsor School
District to build out technology capabilities that wouldn't have
been possible with Windows.

"[The students] are able to do more because Linux cost less,"
Carver said. "Our new computer lab [at Brooks] was set to cost
$35,000 and ended up costing us $16,000 with Linux [on thin
clients]."

And the kids love it too. "The kids think Linux is cool because
it's new, but what they're really doing is stepping into the 21st
century," Carver said.
[/quote]

$2,500 per school to migrate to Linux versus $100,000 per school
to upgrade Windows.  It is not hard to do the math.  OpenOffice
or commercial variant StarOffice meets most office automation
needs.  It reads Office 2003 files and imports them.  No one
wants Office 2007 formats, since they are even incompatible with
earlier Office variants.

Yes, due to the convicted's monopoly maintenance, Windows has dominated for a long time. However, what we are seeing is a developing synergy with Linux, as Governments, school systems and private companies embrace Linux.

This ramping will increase exponentially. The common FUD by Wintrolls will slowly die out, as commercial application delivery shifts to Linux.

We live in exciting times.

--
HPT
Quando omni flunkus moritati
(If all else fails, play dead)
- "Red" Green

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
Author IndexDate IndexThread Index