Home Messages Index
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
Author IndexDate IndexThread Index

[News] Debate Over FSF Freedom and So-called 'Pragmatism'

  • Subject: [News] Debate Over FSF Freedom and So-called 'Pragmatism'
  • From: Roy Schestowitz <newsgroups@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
  • Date: Fri, 25 Jun 2010 14:43:02 +0100
  • Followup-to: comp.os.linux.advocacy
  • Newsgroups: comp.os.linux.advocacy
  • User-agent: KNode/4.4.2
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

New Ground on Terminology Debate?

,----[ Quote ]
| Furthermore, I try to have faith in our 
| community's intelligence. Regardless of how 
| people get drawn into FLOSS: be it from the 
| moral software freedom arguments or the 
| technical-advantage-only open source ones, I 
| don't think people stop listening 
| immediately upon their arrival in our 
| community. I know this even from my own 
| adoption of software freedom: I came for the 
| Free as in Price, but I stayed for the Free 
| as in Freedom. It's only because I couldn't 
| afford a SCO Unix license in 1992 that I 
| installed GNU/Linux. But, I learned within 
| just a year why the software freedom was 
| what mattered most.
| 
| Surely, others have a similar introduction 
| to the community: either drawn in by zero-
| cost availability or the technical benefits 
| first, but still very interested to learn 
| about software freedom. My goal is to reach 
| those who have arrived in the community. I 
| therefore try to speak almost constantly 
| about software freedom, why it's a moral 
| issue, and why I work every day to help 
| either reduce the amount of proprietary 
| software, or increase the amount of Free 
| Software in the world. My hope is that newer 
| community members will hear my arguments, 
| see my actions, and be convinced that a 
| moral and ethical commitment to software 
| freedom is the long lasting principle worth 
| undertaking. In essence, I seek to lead by 
| example as much as possible.
`----

http://ebb.org/bkuhn/blog/2010/06/23/open-source.html

On Annoyance and Free Software

,----[ Quote ]
| I canât name one major Open-Source-not-Free-
| Software activist that offers up any real 
| criticism to the Free Software messaging 
| coming out of the FSF. Thatâs not to say it 
| doesnât exist â  I have covered in this blog 
| a few lawyer and professor types that laid 
| out very intelligent and considered issues 
| on the GPL and Free Software in general, but 
| they are so few and far between.
| 
| The overwhelmingly vast majority of 
| criticism against Free Software basically 
| starts with âFreetardâ and ends with 
| âCommunist/Socialist/Zealotâ. Usually there 
| are a lot of lies and distortions in the 
| middle â I wonder what motivates someone to 
| take a position they are not able to 
| rationally defend, one which they must 
| resort to (and repeat) logical fallacies of 
| all flavors?
`----

http://www.the-source.com/2010/06/on-annoyance-and-free-software/

Why Do Open Source Advocates Attack Each Other?

,----[ Quote ]
| One interesting explanation offered when I 
| asked on Twitter came from Ars Technica's 
| Ryan Paul - himself a key Free software 
| developer as author of the great micro-
| blogging client Gwibber.
| 
| He suggests the situation is precipitated by 
| the influx of new technology strategies such 
| as Software as a Service, mobile, tablet, 
| virtualisation and web services. Since the 
| applicability of software freedom 
| philosophies to these technologies is often 
| unclear, there's no positive rallying-point 
| for activists and the only remaining 
| alternative is to demonise anyone engaging 
| with them. That happens even if the 
| engagement is aimed at subverting or 
| liberating them.
| 
| The articulation of software freedom arose 
| before today's massively-connected society, 
| and today requires thinking and 
| experimentation to make it fit the new 
| reality - hence my work at OSI. 
`----

http://www.computerworlduk.com/community/blogs/index.cfm?entryid=3037

âGnoâ and âGyesâ campaigns - About positive Free Software campaigning

,----[ Quote ]
| But also the FSF already had positive 
| campaigns. Here some recent examples from 
| the FSFs:
| 
|     * Document Freedom Day: The Document 
|     Freedom Day is a day for Document 
|     Freedom and for Open Standards. FSFE did 
|     most of the work for the central 
|     organisation of the DFD in the past 
|     years to promote Open Standards. The FSF 
|     also has a campaign page for Open 
|     Standards.
|     * rOgg On: For this years DFD FSFE 
|     promoted Ogg Vorbis. The German and the 
|     Austrian team encouraged two radio 
|     stations which already use Ogg vorbis, 
|     by giving them a prize and a tart with 
|     the ârOgg Onâ slogon. Deutschlandradio 
|     stated that they Feel more honoured than 
|     for the Grimme Prizeâ. The picutres 
|     clearly show how positive that campaign 
|     was. During that campaign we translated 
|     FSFâs PlayOgg website into German, which 
|     also is a positive campaign.
|     * I love Free Software For this years 
|     Valentineâs Day we started the âI love 
|     Free Softwareâ campaign. People can 
|     show their love to Free Software.
|     * PDFreaders.org FSFEâs Fellows started 
|     a campaign for Free Software PDFreaders 
|     and also explaining Open Standards in 
|     this context.
`----

http://blogs.fsfe.org/mk/?p=593


Recent:

The FSF is needed now - more than ever

,----[ Quote ]
| When would one expect an organisation like
| the Free Software Foundation to be really
| relevant to the world of computing at large -
| when there is a limited threat to freedom in
| computing or when the threat is increasing
| exponentially?
|
| One would think that in the latter case, the
| need for an organisation like the FSF would
| be that much greater. But some people think
| differently. People like Joe "Zonker"
| Brockmeier, for example.
|
| Last week, Brockmeier put forward his views -
| the FSF should not just say no to the use of
| non-free software, things like SaaS (software
| as a service) and devices like the iPad, it
| should provide alternatives, was his take.
`----

http://www.itwire.com/opinion-and-analysis/open-sauce/39881-the-fsf-is-needed-now-more-than-ever
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.10 (GNU/Linux)

iEYEARECAAYFAkwksmYACgkQU4xAY3RXLo7GEACeKbgqRdFRuX/GkFXJXGjF5F4m
TZQAoIAhRjZppcgR8C/RUys6Y6bFHC+Q
=PSre
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
Author IndexDate IndexThread Index