Home Messages Index
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
Author IndexDate IndexThread Index

Re: [News] Why Microsoft Fears Linux



amicus_curious wrote:
"High Plains Thumper" wrote...

This is an example of an ad hominem attack, attacking the writer rather than addressing the points brought up with the
 writer.

Linux has always been considered a threat to the Microsoft Corporation:

Following is a continuation of this ad hominem anti-Linux troll.
Selective snippages, to remove the context, so it can continue
its anti-Linux and ad hominem rants.  This is an example of:

http://www.faqs.org/faqs/linux/advocacy/faq-and-primer/

[quote]
7.6 Trespasser Disinformation Tactics

[quote]
   20. Narrow the scope of threads so that you can handle it.
Narrow the scope of the issues that are being addressed in a
thread to details you feel that you can refute, ridicule, or
dismiss leaving the main issues unaddressed.
[/quote]

Also continuing ad hominem rants of that what I quoted, which is
observations made by several journalists is fictitious by the
following comments, which I followed up with the current.  Also
that Linux computers are now available for sale through major
channels.

Are you for real?  Consider this:

1.  Your cite is some 5 years old.

[quote]
   18. Don't discuss evidence counter to your position. Avoid
examining or discussing evidence counter to your position. This
is especially effective when combined with 3.2.8, Dancing Fool,
wherein you change your position with every post.
[/quote]

2. In the past 5 years, in the face of this terrible threat to their well-being, Windows has prospered.

3. Revenues for Windows client software has more than doubled.

4. Windows server products have moved to a leadership position, eclipsing Unix and IBM operating system based servers, going from virtually no server presence in 2000 to a 41% share today. Linux has managed to steal the low-end business from Unix vendors and is a distant third place in small servers, and fourth place overall.

The above is an example of:

[quote]
   32. Promote Windows at every opportunity.  Microsoft Windows
needs a lot of help to be successful in the mind share of its
targeted user base. Point out to everybody on COLA how wonderful
it is. Ignore the meaning of the name of the newsgroup and its
charter.
[/quote]

If it is the worst threat faced by Microsoft, you had better invest heavily in Mr. Softee for the future.

Interesting that everything comes back to money, stocks, etc.
Also note the interesting, derogatory use of "Mr. Softee" instead
of the proper term "Linux".

These rants seem to be a far cry from "My goal in teaching is to
assist in the development of responsible thinking and soon-to-be
successful people. I try to provide a challenging and motivating
classroom environment."

[snippage reinstated]

http://www.informationweek.com/news/software/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=12800942

or http://tinyurl.com/3uhbpt

[quote] Linux Ranks No. 2 On Microsoft Risk List

The open-source operating system trailed only the economic environment in the biggest risks outlined by CFO John Connors.

By Gregg Keizer, TechWeb News InformationWeek July 18, 2003 03:00 PM

Microsoft (NSDQ: MSFT) is taking the Linux threat seriously.
So seriously, in fact, that open-source software comes in
at the No. 2 spot on the company's top five list of risks.

In a teleconference to go over the Redmond, Wash.-based developer's fourth quarter and fiscal 2003 results on Thursday, CFO John Connors detailed the five biggest risks to his company's business.

"The general economic environment is risk and driver No. 1,"
 he said. "Linux and non-commercial software is risk No. 2."
 [...]

Microsoft has been making noise this year about how serious it takes the threat from open-source software. Microsoft chairman Bill Gates said in February that he took Linux and its threat to his company seriously, saying the operating system is "out there and very pervasive." And in June, CEO Steve Ballmer identified open-source products a major competitive threat in an E-mail sent to all Microsoft employees.

More recently, the company has been stepping up its efforts to convince potential European clients that they should steer away from Linux and towards its products. But even though Ballmer intervened in the attempt to win over the city of Munich, Linux won out.

"When you see these big losses escalating as high as Ballmer," Cherry said, "you know that Linux has caught their
attention." [quote]

http://articles.techrepublic.com.com/5100-22_11-5232985.html

Microsoft: Linux threat is rising Jun 14, 2004 1:34:00 PM By
Graeme Wearden CNET News.com

[quote] More companies are using the threat of Linux when negotiating deals with Microsoft, one of the company's senior executives has admitted.

A year after a letter from Microsoft CEO Steve Balmer to his
employees acknowledged the Linux threat looming on the horizon, Microsoft remains adamant that open-source software
isn't a serious competitor on the desktop today. However,
it may well be forcing Microsoft's prices down.

"It's definitely more of a threat than it was," said Nick Barley, director of marketing at Microsoft, when asked whether more businesses are telling Microsoft that they're planning to migrate to Linux rather than to one of its own operating systems or applications in the hope of getting a better deal. [...]

McGrath also cited a series of recent customer wins, including the London borough of Newham's decision to go with Microsoft rather than open-source options. McGrath claimed that Newham can look forward to potentially twice the productivity-associated cost savings than if they had gone down the open-source road.
http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/category/category_slc.asp?Sort=3D=
Those familiar with the Newham case, though, say it is actually a prime example of Microsoft cutting its prices when facing the threat of Linux. [/quote]

Problem is the Wintrolls herein see it in American eyes, not
in the language or settings of another culture.

http://www.ameinfo.com/46391.html

Is Linux a threat to Microsoft? In the Middle East, the answer depends upon who gets asked the question. But many are now asking such questions about Linux. United Arab Emirates: Saturday, October 02 - 2004 at 13:57

In his wildest dreams, Microsoft founder Bill Gates could not have foreseen that the greatest challenge to his software empire would come from a friendly looking penguin named Tux, the mascot for the open-source operating system Linux.

Named after its originator, Linus Torvalds, Linux is the standard bearer of the open-source software movement. In brief, this means that the code for the operating system - which acts as the layer between the hardware of a computer such as a PC and the applications such as word processing - is not owned by any corporation, but rather belongs to the worldwide community of developers.

This provides tremendous energy and flexibility but does raise issues of support and required in-house technical skills, which have delayed a widespread adoption of Linux. Not any more Ð Linux is now mainstream. [...] At present, there are dozens of ongoing projects for porting Linux to various hardware configurations and purposes. [quote]

Ah, but Linux is profitable:

[quote] As for HP, its Linux-based revenue for the 2003 fiscal year was over $2.5 billion. Following an earlier, similar conversion to the wonders of Java, the big boys see Linux as a key weapon in an ongoing battle for the heart and soul of the IT industry between Microsoft and other key players. [/quote]

.... and the remarkable stability of Linux:

[quote] Linux is inherently a more stable and secure platform than Windows. This is partly because the viruses do not run on Linux, thus security is more robust. Enigmatis recently installed a Windows server that was riddled with viruses and worms within a week.

In sharp contrast, he adds, our Linux server has sat there for over a year without a problem. [/quote]

Ah, then there is the TCO FUD report. It is interesting to note that Forrester no longer does this type of market research:

[quote] These are areas in which Microsoft can, and has, taken the fight back to the Linux camp. One argument that has left many potential users confused is the issue of total
cost of ownership.

Yes, says Microsoft, Linux may be free, but when you factor in other costs such as necessary staff training, rewriting software and so on, then Windows is a better alternative. There is some truth to this, but Microsoft's case was badly hurt by an independent TCO report by leading analysts Forrester that was, it later turned out, funded by the software giant. (Worth noting: Forrester has also now withdrawn from future commercial research of this kind.) [/quote]

Mid-East is heavier into Linux than the Wintrolls would like
to admit:

[quote] Sun shines on Linux

However, not all vendors agree with the cost issue. Mehmet Iyimen, managing director of Sun Microsystems MENA, claims that Linux is proving itself to be a key low-cost computing platform for Middle East enterprises.

Regional customers are using Linux to manage IT infrastructures by matching the right platform to the right task while managing complexity, reducing cost and keeping an
open standards focus. Microsoft is also working hard on the
security issues that have been bedeviling it; although, to be fair, if users were more scrupulous about applying security patches and system updates, then the problems would
not be so great.

According to Torvalds, Microsoft is not in trouble. I think they are struggling to deal with Linux partly because Linux is undermining them the same way they undercut their competition. If you look at DOS, or maybe compilers, one thing that happened with Microsoft was that these upstarts came out and had cheaper compilers.

DOS was also cheap and it undercut the competition, he points out. They never had a competitor like themselves. Then along comes somebody who undercuts them and they start acting exactly how all of their competitors acted. [/quote]

Ah, the clincher, Microsoft is an American company. (Not only the Arabs, but the EU wants to establish its software industries.) The Arabs want independence from Microsoft.

However, specifically in this region, Microsoft faces a major challenge: it is an American company. It can make Arabic a tier-one language for new software releases, but it
can't disguise its origins. That's a problem when there is
a general upswing of anti-American feeling in this part of
the world; fatal in countries where the US government has sanctions in place.

Want legitimate and supported Microsoft software in territories like Syria, Libya and other non- players of the US game? Good luck. Growth forecasts. That's why homegrown support services, based on Linux user groups are mushrooming
across the region.

That's why new Linux training and implementation vendors are
forecasting a good year ahead. That's why homegrown Arabization initiatives - both in IBM's Cairo laboratory and at Riyadh's King Abdul Aziz University for Science and Technology Ð are blossoming.

And that's why, most importantly, a whole region-wide community of Linux developers is spreading across the Middle East, able to use the openness of the operating system to adapt to local demands and to help roll out lower-cost solutions to enterprises and governments who have traditionally used the Unix operating system.

Across the region, enterprises of all sizes and in all market sectors are adopting Linux. The Al Ghurair Group in the UAE is running Oracle applications, as is the Habib AG Zurich Bank, Dubai, which is running core-banking applications with Linux.

Other regional Linux users are the Bahraini government, Saudi Aramco and Emirates Industrial Gases, to name just a few big players making the switch from Microsoft. According to Samer Karawi, HP Middle East's marketing manager, Enterprise Systems Group, Linux will take Unix's market share. Adds Hatem Al-Sibai, group IT manager for the Al Ghurair Group, Our decision to migrate from Windows to Linux was driven by the need to achieve higher uptime for our business while improving information security and reducing cost of ownership. [/quote]

Even so, what do you suppose will happen to the netbook market when a targeted version of Windows 7 is actually available for it? And what if it were predatorially priced to meet any perceived challenge from Linux? Right now, with no such product, the best claim that anyone can make is that Linux is ekeing out 30% of the business and even that is suspect. A cursory glance at Amazon shows that 8 out of the top 10 selling notebooks there use XP and that includes the top 6 models. The return rate on Linux netbooks from people disillusioned with their purchases have been significantly high compared to returns
of XP models as well.

The intial use of Linux on these machines seems to be a flash in the pan that the market is quickly moving to set right.

Ah, so people are so disillusioned that 4 years after the above observations were made, Linux is gaining greater presence even in the US market? Look again:

http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/category/category_slc.asp?Sort=3D=4&Nav=3D|c:2814|&Recs=3D30

PC's configured with Linux:

[quote] 1. Everex CloudBook CE1200V Refurbished Netbook - VIA C7-M ULV 1.2GHz, 802.11b/g Wireless, 512MB DDR2, 30GB HDD, 7" WVGA, Integrated Webcam, gOS V2 Item #: E80-7001 RB Sporting a 7-inch WVGA display, this light as a cloud computer weighs a scant 2 pounds, and offers as much as 5 hours of battery life. $289.99

2. Sylvania G Netbook - VIA C7-M ULV Processor 1.2GHz, 802.11b/g Wireless, 1GB DDR2, 30GB HDD, 7" WVGA, Integrated Webcam, Linux Based gOS Operating System Item #: D516-7001 At just under two pounds, the netbook by Sylvania brings you ultra light portability and wireless Internet connectivity built right in. $299.96

3. Acer Aspire One AOA110-1295 Netbook - Intel Atom=99 Processor N270 1.60GHz, 802.11b/g Wireless, 512MB DDR2, 8GB SSD, 8.9" WSVGA, Integrated Webcam, Linpus Linux Lite Item #: A180-8001 Empower yourself with the incredibly light yet remarkably productive Acer Aspire One =96 the new thin & light notebook that weighs only 2.19 pounds. $349.96

4. Acer Aspire One AOA110-1295 Netbook - Intel Atom=99 Processor N270 1.60GHz, 802.11b/g Wireless, 512MB DDR2, 8GB SSD, 8.9" WSVGA, Integrated Webcam, Linpus Linux Lite Item #: S445-8001 Empower yourself with the incredibly light yet remarkably productive Acer Aspire One =96 the new thin & light netbook that weighs only 2.19 pounds. $349.99

7. Asus Eee PC 4G Netbook - Intel Mobile CPU, 802.11b/g Wireless, 512MB DDR2, 4GB SSD, 7" WVGA, Webcam, Linux, Pearl White Item #: A455-7212 The new Asus Eee PC 4G brings portable computing to the next level. At 7-inches and weighing only 2 pounds, you can take the Eee PC anywhere. $369.99

9. Acer Aspire One AOA110-1626 Netbook - Intel Atom=99 Processor N270 1.60GHz, 802.11b/g Wireless, 1GB DDR2, 16GB SSD, 8.9" WSVGA, Integrated Webcam, Linpus Linux Lite (Onyx Black) Item #: A180-8002 Empower yourself with the incredibly light yet remarkably productive Acer Aspire One =96 the new thin & light netbook that weighs only 2.19 pounds. $369.99

10. Sylvania G Netbook Meso - Intel Atom Processor 1.60GHz, 802.11b/g Wireless, 1GB DDR2, 80GB HDD, 8.9" WSVGA, Integrated Webcam, Ubuntu Netbook Remix (Onyx) Item #: D516-7003 Free yourself from clumsy electronics and enjoy uncompromising mobility with the g netbook. $379.99

11. Sylvania G Netbook Meso - Intel Atom Processor 1.60GHz, 802.11b/g Wireless, 1GB DDR2, 80GB HDD, 8.9" WSVGA, Integrated Webcam, Ubuntu Netbook Remix (Solar) Item #: D516-7004 Free yourself from clumsy electronics and enjoy uncompromising mobility with the g netbook. $379.99

12. Sylvania G Netbook Meso - Intel Atom Processor 1.60GHz, 802.11b/g Wireless, 1GB DDR2, 80GB HDD, 8.9" WSVGA, Integrated Webcam, Ubuntu Netbook Remix (Snow) Item #: D516-7006 Free yourself from clumsy electronics and enjoy uncompromising mobility with the g netbook. $379.99

18. Asus Eee PC 900 Netbook - Intel Mobile CPU, 802.11b/g Wireless, 1GB DDR2, 20GB SSD, 8.9" WSVGA, Integrated Webcam, Linux (Galaxy Black) Item #: A455-9504 You demanded it. We have it! The new 8.9-inch, 2.18-pound Asus Eee PC 900. It=92s easy to learn, work and play when you own an Asus Eee
 PC 900. $429.99

26. Asus Eee PC 901 Netbook - Intel Mobile Atom Processor, Bluetooth, 802.11b/g/n Wireless, 1GB DDR2, 20GB SSD, 8.9" WSVGA, Webcam, Linux (Fine Ebony) Item #: A455-8001 While plenty of PCs promise a revolutionary impact, few deliver the goods. That=92s not the case with our new Asus Eee PC 901. $519.99

27. Asus Eee PC 900 Netbook - Intel Mobile CPU, 802.11b/g Wireless, 1GB DDR2, 20GB SSD, 8.9" WSVGA, Integrated Webcam, Linux (Pearl White) Item #: A455-9500 You demanded it. We have it! The new 8.9-inch, 2.18-pound Asus Eee PC 900. It's
easy to learn, work and play when you own an Asus Eee PC
900. $564.99

28. Asus Eee PC 1000 Netbook - Intel Mobile Atom Processor, Bluetooth, 802.11b/g/n Wireless, 1GB DDR2, 40GB SSD, 10" WSVGA, Webcam, Linux (Fine Ebony) Item #: A455-10002 While plenty of PCs promise a revolutionary impact, few deliver the goods. That=92s not the case with our new Asus Eee PC 1000. $599.99

29. Asus Eee PC 1000 Netbook - Intel Atom Processor, Bluetooth, 802.11b/g/n Wireless, 1GB DDR2, 40GB SSD, 10" WSVGA, Webcam, Linux (Pearl White) Item #: A455-10001 While plenty of PCs promise a revolutionary impact, few deliver the goods. That's not the case with our new Asus Eee PC 1000. $629.99

Page 1 of 2 [/quote]

--
HPT
Quando omni flunkus moritati
(If all else fails, play dead)
- "Red" Green

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
Author IndexDate IndexThread Index