Introduction About Site Map

 XML
RSS 2 Feed RSS 2 Feed
Navigation

Main Page | Blog Index

Thursday, May 12th, 2011, 6:32 pm

Expressions Data in FRGC 2.0 (3-D)

I recently needed to gather 3-D data of different people’s faces, in order to perform experiments on these and test new algorithms that I had developed. The problem was, without some metadata regarding expressions, how might I find correct pairs suiting a particular criterion/ia? Two universities that I contacted had some data of this kind, but they were unwilling to share it (Open Data principles betrayed). So I had to do it myself using a dataset I mentioned here before [1, 2]. So far I have covered smiles and since it takes a lot of time to achieve this, I would like to share my work with those pursuing similar data.

To proactively remove allegations of the set being too easy to deal with (picky-ness in peer review), the most difficult partition when it comes to acquisition quality is taken. The figure below shows some examples of pairs that are being used after being selected as not many images contain expression variation. The selection process of very tedious as very few 3-D images exist with expressions in them, especially ones from the same person (required for consistent training assuming intra-subject residues are alike for common expressions).

Face expressions
Examples of the faces used tor training and recognition, with neutrals on the left and smiles on the right (note: this is just the texture of 3-D images)

About 5 hours were spent classifying the NIST datasets for future experiments. An initial subset of it is put in loader files. From the whole 3-D data of the Face Recognition Grand Challenge, one can only find a few hundreds of distinct individuals. Not all of them have an acquisition with a smile. I found just over 80 by manually browsing everything and some will be hard to work with due to obvious cases of degraded signal. The criteria was that all parts of the face (mouth upwards) must be visible and the expression one of happiness, not necessarily a smile.

The program works reasonably well (see the figure below) with new implementations of ICP (there are two main ones from my research group) and the new data which comprises 86 pairs, or 172 images in total.

Expressions data

Examples of the program with the new data and methods in place

Here is the statement for loading the pairs of expressions in GNU Octave or in MATLAB, in case someone needs a large pile of gigabytes of consistent expressions data.

    images_list={'neutral' 
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04471d273.abs' 


  ;'smile' 
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04471d271.abs' 


  ;'neutral' 
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04472d226.abs' 


  ;'smile' 
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04472d230.abs' 


  ;'neutral' 
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04473d185.abs' 


  ;'smile' 
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04473d193.abs' 


  ;'neutral' 
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04479d222.abs' 


  ;'smile' 
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04479d224.abs' 


  ;'neutral' 
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04484d189.abs' 


  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04484d191.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04485d290.abs'


  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04485d292.abs'

  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04488d286.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04488d288.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04495d313.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04495d317.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04496d246.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04496d250.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04502d60.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04502d58.abs'




































  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04505d218.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04505d224.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04507d309.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04507d305.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04509d276.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04509d282.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04508d83.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04508d85.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04511d178.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04511d176.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04514d326.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04514d328.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04513d303.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04513d309.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04530d321.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04530d323.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04519d204.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04519d210.abs'

  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04531d297.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04531d295.abs'





























  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04537d328.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04537d330.abs'



  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04535d213.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04535d217.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04546d75.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04546d71.abs'



  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04542d118.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04542d114.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04556d311.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04556d315.abs'



  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04557d337.abs'


  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04557d339.abs'

  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04559d314.abs'



  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04559d320.abs'

  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04560d273.abs'


  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04560d275.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04569d288.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04569d286.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04577d290.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04577d292.abs'































  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04580d299.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04580d307.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04581d200.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04581d202.abs'



  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04588d137.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04588d135.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04589d246.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04589d248.abs'



  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04593d200.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04593d202.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04595d93.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04595d95.abs'



  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04596d78.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04596d84.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04600d249.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04600d251.abs'



  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04603d141.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04603d143.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04605d243.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04605d239.abs'








































  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04609d98.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04609d100.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04606d180.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04606d182.abs'



  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04605d255.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04605d253.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04622d238.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04622d240.abs'



  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04619d163.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04619d161.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04629d144.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04629d146.abs'



  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04644d204.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04644d206.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04645d95.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04645d93.abs'



  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04697d80.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04697d78.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04696d40.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04696d42.abs'











































  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04691d50.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04691d48.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04688d40.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04688d36.abs'



  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04684d232.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04684d234.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04682d122.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04682d128.abs'




  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04675d251.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04675d253.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04673d188.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04673d190.abs'




  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04699d42.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04699d44.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04700d18.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04700d20.abs'




  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04703d46.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04703d42.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04704d22.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04704d18.abs'





























































  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04711d53.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04711d47.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04715d12.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04715d14.abs'



  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04717d49.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04717d43.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04719d86.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04719d88.abs'




  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04721d48.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04721d46.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04728d44.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04728d42.abs'




  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04737d38.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04737d36.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04737d38.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04737d36.abs'




  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04749d80.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04749d82.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04750d54.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04750d56.abs'




























































  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04754d78.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04754d80.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04756d73.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04756d75.abs'



  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04762d43.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04762d41.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04763d68.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04763d70.abs'




  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04766d24.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04766d30.abs'


  ;'neutral'  
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04767d38.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04767d36.abs'



  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04768d76.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04768d74.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04773d84.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04773d78.abs'




  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04775d80.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04775d82.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04777d88.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04777d84.abs'


























































  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04779d52.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04779d48.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04805d60.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04805d62.abs'



  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04808d32.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04808d30.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04821d44.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04820d36.abs'




  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04836d47.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04836d49.abs'


  ;'neutral'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04853d50.abs'

  ;'smile'
  ;'~/NIST/FRGC-2.0-dist/nd1/Fall2003range/04853d48.abs'};

Later on I am going to publish all the code and about 100 pages of text. It needs tidying up first.

This entry was posted on Thursday, May 12th, 2011 at 6:32 pm and is filed under Research, Science. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Technical Notes About Comments

Comments may include corrections, additions, citations, expressions of consent or even disagreements. They should preferably remain on topic.

Moderation: All genuine comments will be added. If your comment does not appear immediately (a rarity), it awaits moderation as it contained a sensitive word or a URI.

Trackbacks: The URI to TrackBack this entry is:

https://schestowitz.com/Weblog/archives/2011/05/12/frgc-2-0-smiles/trackback/

Syndication: RSS feed for comments on this post RSS 2
    See also: What are feeds?, Local Feeds

Comments format: Line and paragraph breaks are automatic, E-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Back to top

Retrieval statistics: 21 queries taking a total of 0.116 seconds • Please report low bandwidth using the feedback form
Original styles created by Ian Main (all acknowledgements) • PHP scripts and styles later modified by Roy Schestowitz • Help yourself to a GPL'd copy
|— Proudly powered by W o r d P r e s s — based on a heavily-hacked version 1.2.1 (Mingus) installation —|